Introduction

          This page describes  the  bring-up of RdkWanManager on Raspberry-pi platform using  rdk-next branch. Also, we captured  list of the issues that are faced during bring up and resolution for the same. 

Components

The following components are newly introduced for Porting of  RdkWanManager in RPI Target Platform ,

The following  are the dependent components & meta-layers which are modified, 

RPI Build Steps 

Please refer the below link for host environment set-up & flashing procedure for yocto build ,

Dunfell :

RPI 3B/3B+ Model Reference Platform

Morty:

RDK-B Raspberrypi - Host SetUp and Build Instructions#BRaspberrypi-HostSetUpandBuildInstructions-YoctoBuildSteps

Repo Steps

To  build, follow below instructions

$ mkdir <workspace dir>
$ cd <workspace dir>
$ repo init -u https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/manifests -b dunfell -m rdkb-extsrc.xml 
$ repo sync -j`nproc` --no-clone-bundle
$ mkdir <workspace dir>
$ cd <workspace dir>
$ repo init -u https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/manifests -b rdk-next -m rdkb-extsrc.xml
$ repo sync -j`nproc` --no-clone-bundle

Image Generation Steps


$ MACHINE=raspberrypi-rdk-broadband source meta-cmf-raspberrypi/setup-environment
$ bitbake rdk-generic-broadband-image

Control Flow

Following diagram depicts the flow of control among the components,

                         

Approach

Integration Approach

Manifest Changes


<project name="rdkb/components/opensource/ccsp/RdkWanManager" revision="rdk-next"/>
<project name="rdkb/components/generic/json-rpc" revision="rdk-next"/>

Global CFLAGS

We enabled WanManager CFLAGS in below file in rpi(meta-cmf-raspberrypi) layer,

CFLAGS_append += "${@bb.utils.contains('DISTRO_FEATURES', 'rdkb_wan_manager', ' -DFEATURE_RDKB_WAN_MANAGER ', '', d)}"

Distro Features

We are using the following distro features to enable rdkb wanmanager in RPI machine configuration file,

DISTRO_FEATURES_append = "  rdkb_wan_manager"

Also , we need to disable the GwProvapp-EthWan component in ccsp packagegroup . 

GWPROVAPP = ""


Package Group

To enable the RDKB Wanmanager components, added those components into the final build target.  So, We have added those components into the  ccsp packagegroup(58865),

RDEPENDS_packagegroup-rdk-ccsp-broadband_append = " ${@bb.utils.contains('DISTRO_FEATURES', 'rdkb_wan_manager', ' rdk-wanmanager json-hal-lib hal-json-ethsw', '', d)} "

ethsw(platform-hal)

Utopia CFLAG

Persistent (PSM) configuration changes

For wanmanager, the default configurations are stored in PSM. As of now, we have 1 interfaces defined for WAN in wanmanager modules (i,e) wanoe.

For WANOE, by default we are using `eth0 `port for WAN connection. 

<Record name=""dmsb.wanmanager.if.2.Name"" type=""astr"">eth0</Record>

Example PSM Configurations

 <!-- rdk-wanmanager records -->

   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.wanenable" type="astr">1</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.wanifcount" type="astr">1</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.wanpolicy" type="astr">2</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.wanidletimeout" type="astr">0</Record> 

<!-- X_RDK_WanManager.CPEInterface.1. -wanmanager -->
   <Record name="dmsb.selfheal.rebootstatus"  type="astr">0</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Name" type="astr">eth0</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.DisplayName" type="astr">WanOE</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Enable" type="astr">TRUE</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Type" type="astr">2</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Priority" type="astr">0</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.SelectionTimeout" type="astr">0</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.DynTriggerEnable" type="astr">FALSE</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.DynTriggerDelay" type="astr">0</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Marking.List" type="astr">DATA</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Marking.DATA.Alias" type="astr">DATA</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Marking.DATA.SKBPort" type="astr">1</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Marking.DATA.SKBMark" type="astr"> </Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.Marking.DATA.EthernetPriorityMark" type="astr"></Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.PPPEnable" type="astr">FALSE</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.PPPLinkType" type="astr">PPPoE</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.PPPIPCPEnable" type="astr">TRUE</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.PPPIPV6CPEnable" type="astr">TRUE</Record> 
   <Record name="dmsb.wanmanager.if.1.PPPIPCPEnable" type="astr">TRUE</Record>

Major Errors and Challenges 

S.NoRecipe / Component NamesLayer Error/Warning/challengesRoot CauseAction 
1

ccsp-cr.bbappend

meta-cmf-raspberrypi

CcspEthAgent will start once it gets the signal status from CR but CR is taking long time to send the Signal status .

CR is waiting to get the MTA System_Ready Signal but MTA is not supported for RPI. 

https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdk/components/generic/rdk-oe/meta-cmf-raspberrypi/+/58559/1/recipes-ccsp/ccsp/ccsp-cr.bbappend


2ccsp-psm.bbappendmeta-cmf-raspberrypi

WanManager DM  parameters are not getting the default values from PSM DB


Need to add wanmanager default DM values in PSM databasehttps://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdk/components/generic/rdk-oe/meta-cmf-raspberrypi/+/58559/1/recipes-ccsp/ccsp/ccsp-psm.bbappend
  3utopia.bbappendmeta-cmf-raspberrypi

Below gaps needs to be filled in rpi,

  •   Below initialization activities were done by GWP
    1. /var/run/firewall directory creation.
    2. copying files that are needed by CCSP modules -ccsp_msg.cfg and cp_subsys_ert.
    3. crontab related changes(soft link) 4
    .ipv6/conf/all/forwarding proc entry
  • LAN_start() in ccsp-gwprovapp-ethwan will set
  • sysevents viz. "lan-start", "bridge_mode" and "dhcp_server-resync".
  • Multiple sysevents were set in ccsp-gwprovappethwan: lan-status, wan-status, ethwan-initialized,eth_wan_enabled, wan_service-status, eth_wan_mac,current_ipv4_link_state, current_wan_state,wan_start_time, bridge_mode
  • LAN_start() in ccsp-gwprovapp-ethwan will set
  • sysevents viz. "lan-start", "bridge_mode" and "dhcp_server-resync".
  • Multiple sysevents were set in ccsp-gwprovappethwan: lan-status, wan-status, ethwan-initialized,eth_wan_enabled, wan_service-status, eth_wan_mac,current_ipv4_link_state, current_wan_state,wan_start_time, bridge_mode.
  • In service_wan, execute_dir /etc/utopia/post.d/ restart is being done once the address is set to the WAN interface.
https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdk/components/generic/rdk-oe/meta-cmf-raspberrypi/+/58554/1/recipes-ccsp/util/utopia.bbappend
  4system_defaults (utopia recipe)meta-cmf-raspberrypiAdded WanManager default values to syscfg.dbThese default values are used by PAMhttps://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdk/components/generic/rdk-oe/meta-cmf-raspberrypi/+/58567/1/recipes-ccsp/util/utopia/system_defaults
  5ccsp-p-and-m.bbappendmeta-cmf-raspberrypi

210629-12:11:47.500509 [mod=PAM, lvl=WARN] [tid=8164] Found an unresolved api: Client_GetEntryCount
210629-12:11:47.500664 [mod=PAM, lvl=WARN] [tid=8164] Found an unresolved api: SentOption_GetEntryCount
210629-12:11:47.500810 [mod=PAM, lvl=WARN] [tid=8164] Found an unresolved api: Client3_GetEntryCount
210629-12:11:47.500950 [mod=PAM, lvl=WARN] [tid=8164] Found an unresolved api: Server2_GetEntryCount
210629-12:11:47.501602 [mod=PAM, lvl=WARN] [tid=8164] resolving APIs in xml file failed!                             
210629-12:11:47.501708 [mod=PAM, lvl=WARN] [tid=8164] DslhDmagntLoadDataModelXML -- failed, error = -1!

PandM DM was not loading after the WanManager Integration

Device.DHCPv6.Client.{i} and Device.DHCPv4.Client.{i}. was
moved to the WanManager . But the DMs was not removed from PAM XML file.

https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdk/components/generic/rdk-oe/meta-cmf-raspberrypi/+/58681/2/recipes-ccsp/ccsp/ccsp-p-and-m.bbappend
 6RdkWanManager

RdkWanManager 

RdkWanManager fails to build with the folloiwing errors: | ../../../git/source/WanManager/wanmgr_interface_sm.c:720:62: error: macro LOG_CONSOLE passed 3 arguments, but takes just 0 | 720 | LOG_CONSOLE(%s Wan_init_complete:%d\n,buffer,uptime); | | ^ | In file included from ../../../git/source/WanManager/wanmgr_interface_sm.c:31: | ../../../git/source/WanManager/wanmgr_platform_events.h:48: note: macro LOG_CONSOLE defined here | 48 | #define LOG_CONSOLE() | | | ../../../git/source/WanManager/wanmgr_interface_sm.c:720:9: error: LOG_CONSOLE undeclared (first use in this function) | 720 | LOG_CONSOLE(%s Wan_init_complete:%d\n,buffer,uptime); | |LOG_CONSOLE () api is not definedhttps://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdkb/components/opensource/ccsp/RdkWanManager/+/58500
 7ccsp-common-library.bbappendmeta-cmf-raspberrypiccsp-gwprov-app starts initialization scripts utopia_init.sh

Added utopia.service to call utopia_init.sh 

utopia_init.sh needs to be started before starting of the RdkWanManager executable

https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdk/components/generic/rdk-oe/meta-cmf-raspberrypi/+/58899


https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdk/components/generic/rdk-oe/meta-cmf-raspberrypi/+/58899/5/recipes-ccsp/ccsp/ccsp-common-library/utopia.service

halhal

Device.X_RDK_WanManager.CPEInterface.1.Wan.LinkStatus is getting Incorrect value .

  • Need platform-hal api's development (i.e. hal-ethsw) 

https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdkb/devices/raspberrypi/hal/+/60021/1/source/hal-ethsw/ccsp_hal_ethsw.c

9halhal../../../../../../../../../../rdkb/components/opensource/ccsp/CcspEthAgent/source/TR-181/board_sbapi/cosa_ethernet_apis.c:651: error: undefined reference to 'GWP_GetEthWanLinkStatus'
collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status
Makefile:423: recipe for target 'CcspEthAgent' failed
GWP_GetEthWanLinkStatus() is not defined in eth hal. Earlier, it was defined in GWP-EthWanhttps://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdkb/devices/raspberrypi/hal/+/58785/1/source/hal-ethsw/ccsp_hal_ethsw.c
10rdk-loggerrdk_loggerWANMANAGERLog.txt is not created in /rdklogs/logs folderrdkb_debug.ini and rdkb_log4crc files needs to be updated https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdk/components/generic/rdk_logger/+/58885
11CcspEthAgentCcspEthAgentDevice.X_RDK_WanManager.CPEInterface.1.Wan.LinkStatus  , Device.X_RDK_WanManager.CPEInterface.1.Phy.Path & Device.X_RDK_WanManager.CPEInterface.1.Phy.Status is getting Incorrect values .

1.Fix for erouter0 interface bring up

2.Notifying EthAgent for the link event based on wan_physical_ifname

3.Fix to avoid CR ready check which is causing 1min delay in the ip-assignment flow for ETH.

4.Parameter instance correction for subscribeEvent

https://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdkb/components/opensource/ccsp/CcspEthAgent/+/58898
12CcspPandMCcspPandM../../../../../../../../../../rdkb/components/opensource/ccsp/CcspPandM/source-arm/TR-181/board_sbapi/cosa_dhcpv6_apis.c:8411:56: error: 'hub4_preferred_lft' undeclared (first use in this function)
8411 dhcpv6_data.prefixPltime = hub4_preferred_lft;
^~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
../../../../../../../../../../rdkb/components/opensource/ccsp/CcspPandM/source-arm/TR-181/board_sbapi/cosa_dhcpv6_apis.c:8411:56: note: each undeclared identifier is reported only once for each function it appears in
../../../../../../../../../../rdkb/components/opensource/ccsp/CcspPandM/source-arm/TR-181/board_sbapi/cosa_dhcpv6_apis.c:8412:56: error: 'hub4_valid_lft' undeclared (first use in this function)
8412 dhcpv6_data.prefixVltime = hub4_valid_lft;
^~~~~~~~~~~~~~
hub4_preferred_lft , hub4_valid_lft are not declared properly in pamhttps://code.rdkcentral.com/r/c/rdkb/components/opensource/ccsp/CcspPandM/+/58951

Validation Test Results

erouter0 IPv4 address

                    erouter0 should have valid IP based on the wan configuration (Eg 192.168.0.11/24)


brlan0 IPv4 Address

                         brlan0 IPv4 should be 10.0.0.1 ( i,e Default IP Address )


Able to take SSH from WAN IP

                     ssh from WAN to eRouter IP should be successful

Internet Testing on RPI

LAN client IPv4 and Internet 

                   Lan clients should get IPv4 address in the range of 10 series(i,e default DHCP server pool range) and captive portal page should be loaded.


CCSP Process Status

                All ccsp process should be Up and corresponding DataModel parameters should be loaded properly.


RdkWanManager systemd Status

 

WanManager Logs

                 WanManager logs will be generated in /rdklogs/logs folder in RPI

Systemd Status

          Following systemd service file's status needs to be verfiy,

  1.  utopia
  2.  CcspEthAgent
  3. CcspPandMSsp




Using dmcli commands to verify the LinkStatus(CcspEthAgent will pass the LinkStatus to WanManager )


WebUI Test on RPI

                 WebUI should be loaded in Webbrowser by using erouter0 IPv4 Address(i,e erouter0ip:8080) and login should be successful


Internet check should be successful,



Known Issues

              Sometimes , erouter0 interface is not getting the WAN IP .